Coconut Pumpkin Custard recipe photo
Coconut Pumpkin Custard
Prepared by Sarah Shilhavy, Photo by Jeremiah Shilhavy

Servings: 5
Preparation Time: 8 minutes

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Lightly grease 5 8 oz custard cups/ramekins with coconut oil.

Whip the eggs with a whisk or a blender until smooth. Add remaining ingredients and whisk/blend until smooth and well mixed.

Divide batter between the 5 prepared ramekins. Set the cups into a large baking pan. Fill with 1/2 inch of water.

Bake for 40 minutes (or until knife inserted in middle comes out clean).

Cover each with foil and refrigerate until completely cooled. Top with whipped cream and toasted coconut to serve.

*Use 1 teaspoon of coconut cream concentrate for every 6-8 oz of water for coconut cream milk. Mix together and use as directed or make homemade coconut milk.

Recipe submitted by Carole, Lakewood, CO

Submit your recipe here!


The average is oldaverage based on oldtotal votes.

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
Made it this morning - smells great, but is baking time correct or is there maybe an ingredient missing? I baked for 40 minutes at 350 and it was nowhere near done, so I put it in for an additional 10 minutes, but it's still very runny. I guess I'll keep baking it until it thickens up?
# Posted By Beth | 10/29/09 12:47 PM
When I made it I baked it for longer then 40 minutes also, but the knife came out clean after about ten minutes or so. Just keep baking until it's done. Each oven will vary but if you followed the recipe and used all the ingredients and 5 custard cups then you should be fine. :) Did you do the water bath? That's one thing that's very important as well.
# Posted By Sarah | 10/29/09 3:50 PM
Tried this today and it was delicious!!
# Posted By Sree | 10/31/09 4:34 PM
Can I use Pumpkin Pie Spice instead of all the others? If so, how much would you suggest? Thank you. Sounds delicious.
# Posted By robin dinsmore | 11/21/10 8:47 AM
Robin: Try 2-3 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice.
# Posted By Sarah:) | 11/21/10 12:27 PM
This looks delicious! I love recipes with pumpkin in them and this is one I have to try!
# Posted By Angie | 10/27/11 5:14 PM
I made this with leftover butternut squash, halved the recipe and made 3 great little ramekins. Only 2 are being chilled tonight.
# Posted By Beth | 12/8/11 11:29 PM
Can I pour this into a pie shell and use this as a pumpkin pie filling?
# Posted By Marcia L | 10/27/13 6:22 PM

Weekly Sales
Click Here

Current Sales

FREE Shipping!
Domestic Ground Shipments
FREE Shipping Coupon
Enter Coupon Code
until midnight EDT
April 21st
Wild Caught Fish
50-60% OFF!!
Wild Caught Alaskan Fish
Wild Caught Alaskan Fish
- Pacific Cod Fillets
- Halibut Fillets
- Copper River Sockeye Salmon
until April 20th
Coconut Oil Hair Oils
50% OFF!!
Coconut Oil Hair Oils
8 oz.
Coconut Oil Hair Oils
Retail: $28.00
Now: $14.00
until April 20th
Grass-fed Bison
45% OFF!!
Grass-fed Bison Knuckle Soup bones
approx. 7.5 pounds
Grass-fed Bison
Knuckle Soup Bones
Retail: $59.95
Now: $32.99
until April 20th
Grass-fed Bison
40% OFF!!
Grass-fed Bison NY Strip Steaks
approx. 6 pounds
Grass-fed Bison
NY Strip Steaks
Retail: $219.75
Now: $131.85
until April 20th
Laundry Detergent
50% OFF!!
Powdered Laundry Detergent
5 pounds
Powdered Laundry Detergent
Retail: $30.00
Now: $15.00
until April 20th
Canadian Raw Honey
50% OFF!!

Organic Raw Canadian Honey
17.6 oz.
Canadian Raw Honey
Retail: $20.99
Now: $10.49
until April 24th
Freeze Dried Blueberries
30% OFF!!

Organic Freeze Dried Blueberries
1.2 oz.
Freeze Dried Blueberries
Retail: $6.99
Now: $4.89
until April 24th
Coconut Oil for Pets
50% OFF!!
Coconut Oil for Pets
16 oz.
Coconut Oil for Pets
Retail: $12.50
Now: $6.25
while supplies nearing expiration date last